userkiller wrote:People that make money from seo are selfish.
Here, it's the opposite, we make no money out of sharing everything
More seriously, I truly think that no one should be afraid of sharing an SEO technique, because there is no such trick as add ths line of code in your page and get ranked first on all search engines.
SEO is hard and long term work, and the most part of a site's success is content, not SEO. And sharing thoughts and tricks is a great way to learn, since doing so everyone will find out that this secret trick of his was not so good and that this over one shared by another is a good one, and without anyone jeopardizing its site's success, since again, it all goes down to content quality in the end, not SEO. SEO can only make it happen faster.
And this is even more true when you don't have a lot of money to waist testing paid solutions around.
Then talking about the trick you mentioned, I find this pretty close to organized spam. Of course, it's always good to get involved in related communities / websites, but this is playing with the gray zone. I mean, it's ok if you truly participate, but I personally do not appreciate people posting a single post with a link to their website. We on phpBB SEO consider this as spamming.
On the other hand of course, phpBB SEO users which participate
do get pretty good backlinks. And the backlinks are even better if the page is viewed a lot, meaning if you did put some interesting (thus true) content in it.
Ultimately, do not forget that other search engines are as well good to study your niche and find out about related websites, alexa does not have such a big index.
++